Kneecap Dislocations and Patellar Instability

Will my kneecap dislocate again? For most people, no. The kneecap (patella) rides in a groove on the front of the thigh bone, and the ligament that keeps it centered, the MPFL, tears when the kneecap comes out. Unlike the ACL, that ligament sits outside the joint and can heal on its own, which is why a first dislocation is usually treated without surgery. Whether it stays in afterward depends on your age, the shape of your knee, and how many times it has already happened.

Dr. Brett Raynor is a fellowship-trained orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon in Dallas who treats kneecap dislocations throughout the year as team physician for the U.S. Ski and Snowboard Team, Highland Park High School, St. Mark's School of Texas, Ursuline Academy and Hockaday. He has been named a D Magazine Best Doctor every year since 2019.

Call (214) 265-3211, schedule online, or send an appointment request. A kneecap dislocation is one of the injuries Dr. Raynor's office works in quickly, and during football season the Saturday morning injury clinic sees athletes the morning after a game. If you just hurt your knee, the Fast Track page explains how to get in quickly; you do not need a diagnosis first.

Key points

  • The kneecap almost always dislocates toward the outside of the knee, and it tears the MPFL on the way out.

  • A first dislocation is usually treated without surgery. About 1 in 3 people will have it happen again; the rest heal and never need an operation.

  • Once it has happened more than once, the odds of another dislocation climb to about 1 in 2, and higher still in people whose anatomy makes the kneecap want to come out.

  • Every dislocation can knock a piece of cartilage off the back of the kneecap. A loose piece of cartilage is the one thing that makes surgery urgent.

  • MPFL reconstruction, a new ligament made from donor tendon, keeps the kneecap in place in more than 95 of 100 knees.


Watch the video above for Dr. Raynor’s explanation of patellar instability and some of the most common treatment options.

Click through the guide below to learn about kneecap dislocations and how they are treated.

The walkthrough as text

The same walkthrough you can tap through above, written out so you can read it, print it or search it. Tap a chapter to open it.

This short guide covers how the kneecap stays in place, what happens when it dislocates, why some knees are built for it, and how an MPFL reconstruction works, using the same drawings Dr. Raynor uses in the exam room. It takes about three minutes.

1. How the kneecap dislocates
  1. The kneecap rides in a groove at the end of the thigh bone.
  2. When the kneecap dislocates, it almost always goes toward the outside of the knee.
  3. To travel that far, the kneecap has to tear the MPFL, the medial patellofemoral ligament, the main ligament holding it on the inside.
  4. Most of the time it pops straight back in. On the way, the kneecap bumps the thigh bone, which leaves a bruise on each bone on the MRI.
2. Healing, and when it happens again
  1. The MPFL sits outside the joint, like the MCL, so it can heal on its own. That is why most first-time dislocations are treated without surgery.
  2. If it happens again, the ligament has healed loose. Each dislocation makes the next one more likely, and that is when surgery comes into the conversation.
  3. Sometimes a dislocation knocks a piece of cartilage and bone off the back of the kneecap. A loose piece in the joint is the one reason to operate right away.

Of 100 people after a first dislocation, about 1 in 3 dislocate again. After more than one, about 1 in 2, and the odds keep climbing with each one.

3. Your options
  1. A reconstruction is the same operation now or a year from now, so there is no rush. The choices are living with it, physical therapy with a kneecap-tracking brace, or surgery.
  • Live with it. Do nothing and see how it goes.
  • Physical therapy and a kneecap brace. Strengthen the quad, with a small patellar tracking brace for a while. Never wrong, and it gets the knee ready if surgery comes later.
  • Fix it. MPFL reconstruction. Same operation now or a year from now. An MRI first, for the measurements and to look at the cartilage.

The old way was to tighten the torn ligament (a reefing), and about 1 in 3 dislocated again. With a new ligament (MPFL reconstruction), about 1 to 4 in 100 dislocate again.

4. MPFL reconstruction, step by step
  1. When it needs surgery, the most common operation is an MPFL reconstruction: a new ligament made from donor tendon, so nothing is taken from your own knee. There is a small incision beside the kneecap, one on the inside of the thigh, and two small arthroscopy portals.
  2. The new ligament starts at two small anchors, made entirely of suture, set into the inside edge of the kneecap.
  3. A small socket is drilled in the thigh bone where the original ligament attached.
  4. The donor tendon is passed into the socket and held there with a screw that dissolves over time.
  5. The new ligament is tensioned to catch the kneecap without limiting how the knee bends, and secured to the kneecap. The result is a new MPFL.
5. Why some knees are built for it
  1. Some knees are built in a way that makes the kneecap more likely to go out. Some people are born with a shallow groove, so the kneecap sits on something more like an ice rink than a track. This is called trochlear dysplasia.
  2. In the most severe form the groove is shaped like a mountain and the kneecap teeters on top of it. Those knees are the most unstable.
  3. With the knee straight, the kneecap sits above its groove. As the knee bends, it drops into the groove, and once it is in, it is stable. A kneecap that sits high, called patella alta, takes a little longer to get there. The MPFL is what pulls it back in when it starts to go.
  4. The quadriceps tendon runs into the top of the kneecap, and the patellar tendon runs from the bottom of the kneecap to a bump on the shin bone. Normally they line up, so the pull runs nearly straight.
  5. If that attachment sits too far to the outside, every time the thigh muscle fires it pulls the kneecap outward. This is measured on the MRI.
6. When the bone needs to move too
  1. For some of these knees, a second procedure is added to the MPFL reconstruction: a tibial tubercle osteotomy. The piece of bone the tendon attaches to is cut free, rather than the tendon itself, because bone heals to bone reliably.
  2. That piece of bone is moved inward and forward, back in line, and held with two screws. It is added only when the anatomy calls for it.
7. Recovery
  1. It is a same-day surgery. You walk on it right away in a brace with crutches, walk normally at about six weeks, and the ligament is healed by three months. Full return to sport is around six months, once the thigh muscle is back to ninety percent.
  • Day 0: day surgery; walking on it and moving it right away, with a brace and crutches.
  • 3 to 4 weeks: brace until the quad wakes up. Stairs: up with the good leg, down with the bad.
  • 6 weeks: walking normally, no crutches, brace off.
  • 3 months: ligament healed; jogging progression and the gym as normal.
  • 6 months: full competitive sports, once the quad is 90 percent of the other side.
  • With a tubercle move: toe-touch weight bearing for 6 weeks and staged motion. Slower.

Most high school students miss about five days of school: surgery on a Thursday, back at a desk on crutches by the next Tuesday or Wednesday.

See the full MPFL reconstruction recovery roadmap

The walkthrough is narrated by M. Brett Raynor, M.D., orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon, Texas Orthopaedic Associates, Dallas, and uses the same drawings he uses in the exam room. Last reviewed 11/3/2026. General information for patients; it does not replace an examination.

What keeps the kneecap in place

The kneecap sits in a groove at the end of the thigh bone (the trochlea) and glides up and down in it as the knee bends and straightens. With the knee straight, the kneecap actually rides above the groove. As the knee starts to bend, the kneecap has to drop into the groove, and in the first few degrees of bend it is the soft tissue on the inside of the knee that steers it there. The main thickening of that tissue is the medial patellofemoral ligament, the MPFL, which runs from the inside edge of the kneecap to the inside of the thigh bone. Think of it as a check-rein: if the kneecap starts to slide toward the outside, the MPFL pulls it back toward the groove.

Once the knee is bent past about 30 degrees, the groove itself does most of the work, and the deeper the groove, the harder the kneecap is to dislocate. The quadriceps muscle, especially its inner portion, helps pull the kneecap toward the center as well.

What happens when the kneecap dislocates

A kneecap dislocation almost always goes the same direction: toward the outside of the knee. It usually happens with the knee slightly bent and the body twisting over a planted foot, as in a cut, a landing, or a tumbling pass, when the thigh muscles fire just as the kneecap is deciding whether to drop into its groove. For the kneecap to travel that far, the MPFL has to tear or pull off the bone. Then the kneecap either goes back in on its own, often when the leg straightens, or it is put back by a trainer or in the emergency room.

On the way out and back in, the inside edge of the kneecap strikes the outside edge of the thigh bone. That collision is what leaves the two bone bruises an MRI shows afterward, and it can chip cartilage off the back of the kneecap or the edge of the thigh bone. In a study of 39 knees examined arthroscopically after a first dislocation, 95 percent had some cartilage injury on the back of the kneecap, ranging from surface cracks to a chipped-off piece (Nomura et al., Arthroscopy, 2003). On MRI within eight weeks of a first dislocation, 70 percent of knees showed bone or cartilage injury at the inner lower corner of the kneecap, and 15 percent had a loose piece floating in the joint (Elias et al., Radiology, 2002).

Sometimes the kneecap comes out and goes back in so fast that the person never sees it. The knee swells, it hurts along the inside of the kneecap, and the diagnosis is made in the office from the exam and the pattern of bruising on the MRI.

Two kinds of instability

A dislocation after an injury. This is the common pattern: a normal knee, a twisting injury, and a kneecap that comes out and goes back in. The MPFL is torn, and the question is whether it heals well enough to keep the kneecap in. Sometimes the kneecap does not fully dislocate; it slips partway out and snaps back (a subluxation). A subluxation injures the same tissue and carries the same risk of happening again.

A kneecap that was never well seated. Some people have anatomy that makes the kneecap want to come out: a groove that is too shallow or even rounded like a hill, so the kneecap teeters on top of it instead of sitting in it (trochlear dysplasia); a kneecap that rides high and drops into the groove late (patella alta); a patellar tendon that attaches farther toward the outside of the shin than usual, so the pull of the thigh muscle angles the kneecap outward; or simply loose ligaments throughout the body. These knees can dislocate with very little force, sometimes without a real injury at all, and they are the knees most likely to keep dislocating. In a classic study of 143 knees operated on for instability, a shallow groove was present in 85 percent and an outward-set tendon attachment in 56 percent, compared with 3 to 6 percent of normal knees (Dejour et al., Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc, 1994). People with this anatomy can usually blame their parents for it, and it changes the conversation about surgery.

Symptoms of patellar instability

  • A visible deformity at the moment of injury, with the kneecap sitting on the outside of the knee, that resolves when it goes back in

  • A pop or a tearing sensation, followed by rapid swelling of the whole knee

  • Pain and tenderness along the inside edge of the kneecap, where the MPFL tore

  • A feeling that the kneecap is loose or might slip, especially when the knee is slightly bent and twisting

  • A sense of apprehension when the kneecap is pushed toward the outside, which is the sign Dr. Raynor looks for on exam

  • In people with unfavorable anatomy, a kneecap that visibly shifts outward (a J-sign) as the knee straightens

A kneecap dislocation and an ACL tear can feel alike in the moment: a pop, a swollen knee, and a leg that will not hold weight. They are different injuries with very different plans, and part of the first visit is making sure the ACL is intact.

Will it dislocate again?

This is the question that decides treatment, and the research gives a clear answer. For a first dislocation treated without surgery, a review that pooled 17 studies found that about 1 in 3 people (33.6 percent) dislocate again (Huntington et al., Am J Sports Med, 2020). In adults followed for two to five years, the figure was lower, 17 percent, and the kneecap was six times more likely to come out again in people who had already dislocated before (Fithian et al., Am J Sports Med, 2004).

Those odds are not the same for everyone. Once the kneecap has dislocated more than once, the chance of it happening again is about 1 in 2 (49 percent in the Fithian study). Young patients whose growth plates are still open are at higher risk; in a population study from the Mayo Clinic, more than half of skeletally immature patients dislocated again within 15 years (Sanders et al., Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc, 2018). Anatomy stacks the odds further. A shallow groove, a high-riding kneecap, an outward-set tendon attachment and young age each raise the risk, and with three of those factors present, the chance of another dislocation was 70 to 79 percent in the pooled review (Huntington et al., Am J Sports Med, 2020). In adolescents with open growth plates and a shallow groove, 69 percent dislocated again (Lewallen et al., Am J Sports Med, 2013).

Dr. Raynor's rule in the office is simple: you get one free dislocation. For a first-time dislocation in a knee with reasonable anatomy, the plan is to let the MPFL heal and make the knee prove it needs surgery. If it comes out a second time, it has proven it, and the conversation turns to surgery.

What each dislocation costs

A dislocation is not just an event; it leaves marks. The cartilage injury described above happens with the first dislocation and can happen again with each one after it. A loose piece of cartilage and bone in the joint will not heal back in place on its own, and it can catch, lock the knee, and grind on the surfaces around it. In a series of children and adolescents seen after a first dislocation, 38 percent had a bone and cartilage fracture on MRI, and almost half of those had been read as normal on plain X-rays (Seeley et al., J Pediatr Orthop, 2013).

The long-term cost is arthritis under the kneecap. A Mayo Clinic study followed 609 people for an average of 12 years after a first dislocation and compared them with matched people who had never dislocated. At 25 years, nearly half of the dislocation group (49 percent) had symptomatic arthritis under the kneecap, against 8 percent of the comparison group. The risk was highest in people who had chipped cartilage at the first dislocation (11 times the risk), who dislocated repeatedly (4.5 times), or who had a shallow groove (3.6 times) (Sanders et al., Am J Sports Med, 2017). That is the strongest argument for not letting a kneecap keep coming out.

How patellar instability is diagnosed

The history usually tells the story: what the knee was doing, which way the kneecap went, whether it went back in on its own. On exam, Dr. Raynor checks the ACL and the other ligaments first, then watches the kneecap track as the knee slowly straightens, and last tests whether pushing the kneecap toward the outside produces the apprehension that marks an unstable knee. X-rays show whether a piece of bone came off with the cartilage and whether the kneecap sits high in the groove.

The MRI answers two questions. First, is there a chunk of cartilage loose in the knee? That is the one finding that forces surgery right away. Second, what does the anatomy look like? The MRI shows how deep the groove is and allows a measurement of how far toward the outside the patellar tendon attaches (the TT-TG distance), which together predict how likely the kneecap is to come out again and what kind of surgery would be needed if it does. The two bone bruises, one on the inside of the kneecap and one on the outside of the thigh bone, are the footprints of the dislocation, and they confirm the diagnosis when nobody saw the kneecap out.

Treatment without surgery

For a first dislocation without a loose piece of cartilage, Dr. Raynor treats the knee without surgery, and most patients never need anything more. The plan has three parts.

Let the ligament heal. For the first two weeks the knee stays in a brace locked straight for walking and sleeping. With the knee straight the kneecap sits above its groove, where it is much less likely to dislocate, and keeping it there lets the torn MPFL settle back in. The knee can bend to sit. Crutches are for balance only; walking normally on crutches is better than limping without them.

Protect and strengthen. At the two-week visit the straight brace is traded for a smaller kneecap-stabilizing brace, worn for about a month when up and around, and physical therapy begins: getting the motion back, calming the swelling, and waking up the quadriceps, which shuts down quickly after a swollen knee and comes back slowly. Some stiffness along the inside of the knee at this stage is a good sign; it means the tissue is healing in.

Earn the way back. Return to sport is not a date. It is full motion, full strength, and the ability to cut, pivot and twist without hesitation. Before an athlete returns to a cutting sport, Dr. Raynor has the therapist run a sport test, and the quadriceps has to be at least 90 percent as strong as the other leg. That gate is less about the kneecap than about the ACL: a weak quad in a cutting athlete is how a second, worse injury happens. For most first-time dislocators that works out to about four to six weeks for competitive sports, with the brace on for the first few weeks back and then set aside once the knee feels trustworthy.

Does surgery after a first dislocation prevent the second one? Operating on first-time dislocators has been studied in randomized trials, and simply repairing or tightening the torn tissue has not reliably done better than rehabilitation (Erickson et al., Arthroscopy, 2015); in children and adolescents, a randomized trial found no advantage to early repair at long-term follow-up (Palmu et al., J Bone Joint Surg Am, 2008). That is why the first dislocation is treated without surgery, and why the operation Dr. Raynor does when surgery is needed is a reconstruction, not a repair.

When surgery is the right call

Three situations lead to surgery.

A loose piece of cartilage. If the dislocation knocked a sizable piece of cartilage and bone off the kneecap or the thigh bone, it needs to be fixed back in place or removed, and that is done promptly. When Dr. Raynor is already in the knee for the cartilage, the MPFL is usually reconstructed at the same time.

A second dislocation. Once the kneecap has come out twice, the odds of a third are about 1 in 2, and each dislocation risks more cartilage. At that point Dr. Raynor recommends MPFL reconstruction: a new ligament, made from donor tendon, that runs from the inside of the kneecap to the inside of the thigh bone and holds the kneecap in if it starts to make the wrong decision. The old approach of cutting and sewing the stretched tissue tighter failed in about 1 in 3 knees (Camp et al., Am J Sports Med, 2010); after reconstruction, the kneecap dislocated again in about 1 in 100 patients across 14 studies (Schneider et al., Am J Sports Med, 2016), and in 3.7 percent of 629 knees in a review that also counted partial slips (Shah et al., Am J Sports Med, 2012).

Unfavorable anatomy with recurrent instability. When the patellar tendon attaches far toward the outside of the shin, a new ligament alone is fighting the angle of pull. In those knees Dr. Raynor may also move the bony attachment of the patellar tendon toward the inside and forward, which straightens the line of pull and takes pressure off the kneecap cartilage. It is a bigger operation with a longer recovery, and he reserves it for knees that have proven they need it.

There is no rush. Because the surgery is a reconstruction rather than a repair, it is the same operation six months or a year after the injury as it would be today. The only thing that forces an early operation is a loose piece of cartilage. For a high school athlete in season, that means the knee can often be rehabilitated, braced and played on, with the reconstruction scheduled for the off-season.

For how Dr. Raynor does the operation, step by step, see MPFL reconstruction.

Why patients choose Dr. Raynor for patellar instability

Dr. Raynor's practice is built around knee ligament injuries in athletes. He is the team physician for the U.S. Ski and Snowboard Team, Highland Park High School, St. Mark's School of Texas, Ursuline Academy and Hockaday, which means he sees kneecap dislocations the day after they happen and follows those athletes through the season and back onto the field. He trained at the Steadman Philippon Research Institute in Vail, one of the leading sports medicine fellowships in the country, after an orthopaedic surgery residency at Vanderbilt.

His approach to a first dislocation is deliberately conservative: let it heal, get the quad back, and make the knee prove it needs an operation. When surgery is the right call, MPFL reconstruction is one of his most reliable operations, and he adds the bone work only when the anatomy requires it. Every patient leaves with a stage-by-stage plan and a direct line to the team.

The research, and common questions

The sections below collect the studies behind the numbers on this page and answer the questions patients ask most often.

Dr. Raynor has also written longer answers to common questions about kneecap dislocations:

Make an appointment

A kneecap that has dislocated deserves an exam within days, not weeks: the brace, the therapy and the MRI decision all start at the first visit. Call (214) 265-3211, schedule online, or send an appointment request. Dr. Raynor sees patients at Texas Orthopaedic Associates, 7115 Greenville Avenue, Suite 310, Dallas.

Written and medically reviewed by M. Brett Raynor, M.D., board-certified orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon. Last reviewed 11/3/2026. General information for patients; it does not replace an examination.