Shoulder Dislocations and Shoulder Instability

Will my shoulder dislocate again? For a young athlete, more often than not. The shoulder is the most mobile joint in the body, and the same shallow socket that lets it move so freely is what lets it come out. A first dislocation usually tears the labrum, the rim of tissue that keeps the ball centered, and once that bumper is torn the shoulder is easier to dislocate the next time. Whether to repair it, and when, depends on your age, your sport, and what the shoulder has already been through.

Dr. Brett Raynor is a fellowship-trained orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon in Dallas who treats shoulder dislocations every season as team physician for the U.S. Ski and Snowboard Team, Highland Park High School and St. Mark's School of Texas, and whose published research on shoulder instability includes a multicenter study of how instability is classified and an outcomes study of arthroscopic stabilization for loose shoulders. He has been named a D Magazine Best Doctor every year since 2019.

Call (214) 265-3211, schedule online, or send an appointment request. During football season, the Saturday morning injury clinic sees athletes the morning after a game. If you just hurt your shoulder, the Fast Track page explains how to get in quickly; you do not need a diagnosis first.

Key points

  • Most dislocations go out the front and tear the labrum on the way out. The dislocation is the event; the torn labrum is the injury.

  • Age is the biggest predictor of a second dislocation. Without surgery, about two out of three patients between 15 and 35 have the shoulder come out or slip again within five years.

  • Each dislocation can chip bone from the edge of the socket, and bone loss is what turns a routine arthroscopic repair into a bigger operation.

  • A labral repair cuts the chance of further instability (a full dislocation or a partial slip) from roughly two in three to about one in ten.

What holds the shoulder in place

The shoulder is a ball and socket, but the socket is shallow: picture a golf ball sitting on a tee. Three things keep the ball on the tee. The labrum is a rim of firm tissue around the edge of the socket that deepens it, like a bumper. Ligaments run from the ball to the labrum and tighten as the arm goes up and out. And the rotator cuff muscles pull the ball into the socket with every motion. Most of the shoulder's stability comes from those soft tissues, which is why a tear in them matters so much.

What happens when the shoulder dislocates

In most dislocations the ball comes out the front of the socket, usually with the arm up and out to the side, as in a tackle, a fall on an outstretched arm, or a hard throw. On the way out it tears the labrum away from the front edge of the socket (a Bankart tear) and stretches the ligaments. Then it goes back in, on its own or with help in the emergency room or on the sideline. In a study of young patients examined arthroscopically within ten days of a first dislocation, 97 percent had the labrum and ligaments torn from the socket (Taylor and Arciero, Am J Sports Med, 1997).

The back of the ball usually picks up a dent where it struck the edge of the socket, called a Hill-Sachs lesion. In that same study it was present in 57 of 63 shoulders, and none were large. The dent matters mainly if the shoulder keeps coming out. Less often the ligaments tear from the ball instead of the socket (a HAGL lesion); that is uncommon, but it changes the repair, so Dr. Raynor looks for it on every MRI.

SLAP tears (tears of the top of the labrum, where the biceps tendon attaches) are a different problem, usually without instability. The SLAP tears page covers them.

The walkthrough as text

The same walkthrough you can tap through above, written out so you can read it, print it or search it. Dr. Raynor narrates it in his own words. Tap a chapter to open it.

This short guide covers what holds your shoulder in, what happens when it comes out, and what we can do about it, using the same illustrations I use in the exam room. It takes about three minutes.

1. What holds it in place
  1. The shoulder is often compared to a golf ball sitting on a tee. This view looks down on it from above. The shallow socket gives the shoulder its wide range of motion, but it also makes dislocation possible.
  2. Several structures hold the ball in place. The labrum is a rim of tissue around the edge of the socket that deepens it, like a bumper.
  3. Ligaments run from the ball to the labrum and help keep the ball centered.
2. When it dislocates
  1. Most dislocations happen toward the front. As the ball comes out, it often tears the labrum away from the edge of the socket before it returns to place.
  2. The back of the ball often gets a small dent where it struck the edge of the socket, called a Hill-Sachs lesion. It is usually small and matters mainly if dislocations continue.
  3. The labrum may heal back in place. If it does not, or if the ligaments are stretched, the shoulder becomes more likely to dislocate again.
  4. Recurrence is the main concern after a dislocation. Among 100 young athletes treated with a sling and rehabilitation, about 67 have the shoulder come out or slip again (recurrent instability); after surgical repair, about 10 do. Young men in contact sports are at the highest risk.
  5. Each dislocation can cause more damage: the dent can enlarge and the edge of the socket can chip, like a golf tee with a chip in it. This makes further dislocations more likely.
3. Treatment options
  1. Treatment usually begins with rehabilitation. Physical therapy strengthens the rotator cuff muscles, which help hold the shoulder in place.
  2. While the shoulder recovers, avoid the position in which it tends to dislocate: arm raised, out to the side, and rotated back. Avoid reaching awkwardly overhead or behind you.
  3. If the shoulder feels stable after rehabilitation, surgery is not needed. If it remains unstable or dislocates again, surgical repair is recommended. Waiting risks additional dislocations.
4. If surgery is needed
  1. In surgery, small anchors made of suture are placed in the bone, and the labrum and ligaments are reattached to the edge of the socket. The procedure is done arthroscopically, through a few small incisions.
  2. Viewed straight on, a repair usually uses three anchors, sometimes four. The repair also tightens the ligaments around the joint.
  3. If a significant amount of bone has been lost from the socket, an arthroscopic repair is less reliable. In that case a procedure that rebuilds the edge of the socket may be recommended, and Dr. Raynor will discuss what that means for you.
  4. Recovery: surgery is outpatient, followed by six weeks in a sling. Strengthening begins at three months, throwing at about five months, and contact sports at about six months.
Before your visit

If you are scheduled to see me, here are a few things to consider before your visit, so we can make the most of our time together:

Things to consider

  • How many times has it come out?
  • Did someone have to put it back in, or did it go back on its own?
  • What sport and position do you play, and is your season going on now?
  • What position makes it feel like it might slip?
  • What do you want to get back to doing?

Questions you may want to ask

  • How likely is it to come out again?
  • Can I finish my season?
  • Is there any bone loss?
  • What’s the next step for me?

See the shoulder stabilization recovery roadmap

The walkthrough is narrated by M. Brett Raynor, M.D., orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon, Texas Orthopaedic Associates, Dallas, and uses the same drawings he uses in the exam room. Last reviewed 10/11/2026. General information for patients; it does not replace an examination.

Two kinds of instability

Instability after a dislocation. The most common pattern by far is a single traumatic dislocation out the front, followed by the occasional repeat; in a multicenter study of 383 instability patients that Dr. Raynor co-authored, those two categories alone accounted for four in ten patients (Hettrich et al., J Shoulder Elbow Surg, 2019). Sometimes the shoulder does not fully dislocate; it slips partway out and snaps back (a subluxation). A subluxation tears the same tissue and carries the same risk of recurrence. Less often the shoulder goes out the back, typically from a fall on the arm or from blocking in football; a posterior labral tear is repaired the same way, with its own set of precautions afterward.

A loose shoulder that has never dislocated (multidirectional instability). Some people, often swimmers, gymnasts, volleyball players and throwers, have shoulders that are loose in more than one direction without a single injury. That is multidirectional instability, and it starts with rehabilitation, not surgery. The section on treatment without surgery covers it.

Symptoms of shoulder instability

  • A dislocation that needed to be put back in, or a shoulder that popped out and went back on its own

  • A sense that the shoulder is about to slip when the arm is up and out to the side, as in throwing or reaching behind you

  • A sudden "dead arm" feeling or weakness with an overhead or throwing motion

  • Pain deep in the shoulder after an episode, often with clicking or catching

  • A shoulder you no longer trust in the position it came out in

Will it dislocate again?

This is the question that decides everything else, and the answer depends mostly on age. In a prospective study of 252 patients aged 15 to 35 treated with a sling and physical therapy after a first anterior dislocation, 56 percent dislocated again within two years and 67 percent within five years, with young men at the highest risk (Robinson et al., J Bone Joint Surg Am, 2006). Across the adult literature, recurrence runs about 39 percent overall, and being 40 or younger, being male, and having naturally loose joints each raise it (Olds et al., Br J Sports Med, 2015). In the youngest, most active group, cadets under 24, the recurrence rate without surgery was 90 percent (Taylor and Arciero, Am J Sports Med, 1997). The risk falls with age, and after 40 a first dislocation is more likely to stay a one-time event.

Male contact athletes under 25 sit at the top of the risk curve, and they are the patients Dr. Raynor most often advises to have the shoulder repaired rather than wait for the next dislocation.

What each dislocation costs

A dislocation is not a free event, even when the shoulder goes right back in. Each one can enlarge the labral tear, stretch the ligaments further, and chip bone from the edge of the socket. In a prospective MRI study of athletes, a single instability event removed an average of about 7 percent of the socket's width, and athletes with recurrent instability had lost about 23 percent (Dickens et al., Am J Sports Med, 2019). The golf tee gets a chip in it, the ball falls off more easily, and an arthroscopic repair becomes less reliable. The dent in the back of the ball deepens at the same time.

Over the long run, repeated dislocations are also hard on the cartilage. In a Swedish study that followed 223 shoulders for 25 years after a first dislocation, moderate or severe arthritis developed in 18 percent of shoulders that never dislocated again, 39 percent of shoulders that kept dislocating without surgery, and 26 percent of shoulders that were surgically stabilized (Hovelius and Saeboe, J Shoulder Elbow Surg, 2009).

The surgery to repair a torn labrum is the same whether it is done after the first dislocation or the fifth. What changes with each dislocation is whether that surgery is still enough.

How shoulder instability is diagnosed

Dr. Raynor starts with the story: how the shoulder came out, whether it has happened before, and what sport and position you play. The examination checks the direction the shoulder wants to go, how much the ligaments have stretched, and the strength of the rotator cuff. X-rays show the alignment and any bone chipped from the socket. An MRI, usually with dye injected into the joint, shows the labrum, the ligaments, the Hill-Sachs dent and the rotator cuff; it is ordered when its result would change the plan, and always before surgery. When bone loss is a concern, a CT scan measures it.

Treatment without surgery

For a first dislocation in a lower-risk patient, and for most multidirectional instability, treatment starts with rehabilitation. A sling for a short period, mostly for comfort; keeping a young patient in a sling for weeks has not been shown to lower the chance of a second dislocation (Paterson et al., J Bone Joint Surg Am, 2010). Then physical therapy to strengthen the rotator cuff and the muscles that steer the shoulder blade, since they can compensate for stretched ligaments. In the meantime, staying out of the position the shoulder likes to come out in: arm up, out to the side, and rotated back. Reaching under a bed or behind the car seat is how it happens.

Loose shoulders that have never dislocated do well with this program more often than not. When they do not, tightening the capsule arthroscopically is the next step. Dr. Raynor's own outcomes study of that operation in athletes found that 87 percent of shoulders had no further instability at three years and 77 percent of patients returned to sports at or near their previous level (Raynor et al., Am J Sports Med, 2016).

Playing through the season

Athletes who dislocate mid-season often want to finish it. Sometimes that is reasonable. In a prospective study of 45 college contact athletes, 73 percent returned to play in the same season, at a median of five days, but 64 percent of those who returned had another instability episode before the season ended (Dickens et al., Am J Sports Med, 2014). Dr. Raynor makes this decision with the athlete, the family and the athletic trainer: rehabilitation and often a brace, a clear understanding that it may come out again, and the repair scheduled for the end of the season. What matters is that it is a decision, made with the numbers on the table.

When surgery is the right call

Surgery is recommended when:

  • The shoulder has dislocated more than once, or still feels unstable after a course of rehabilitation

  • A young contact or overhead athlete has had a first dislocation and wants one repair and one recovery rather than a recurring problem. In a meta-analysis of ten prospective studies, arthroscopic repair after a first dislocation lowered the recurrence rate from 67 percent to about 10 percent and raised the rate of return to play (Hurley et al., Arthroscopy, 2020)

  • Imaging shows a tear that will not heal in position, or bone chipped from the socket

  • The shoulder cannot be trusted in the positions your sport or work requires

The operation is an arthroscopic labral repair: the torn labrum and ligaments are reattached to the edge of the socket with small anchors, through a few small incisions, as an outpatient surgery. How Dr. Raynor performs shoulder stabilization covers the steps, the add-ons for the dent and for bone loss, and how often the repair holds. Recovery is six weeks in a sling, strengthening from three months, and a return to sports between four and six months; the shoulder stabilization recovery roadmap walks through every stage.

Why patients choose Dr. Raynor for shoulder instability

  • Fellowship-trained in sports medicine at the Steadman Philippon Research Institute in Vail, Colorado

  • Published research on shoulder instability: first author of an outcomes study of arthroscopic stabilization for multidirectional instability in athletes (American Journal of Sports Medicine, 2016) and co-author of the multicenter studies behind the FEDS classification of shoulder instability (Journal of Shoulder and Elbow Surgery; Orthopaedic Journal of Sports Medicine)

  • Team physician for the U.S. Ski and Snowboard Team, Highland Park High School, St. Mark's School of Texas, Hockaday and Ursuline Academy, so unstable shoulders in contact athletes, and return-to-play decisions, are a regular part of his week

  • Board-certified orthopaedic surgeon; D Magazine Best Doctor every year since 2019

  • More than 800 five-star Google reviews

The research, and common questions

Expand any section below.

Dr. Raynor has also written longer answers to common questions about shoulder dislocations:

Make an appointment

Call (214) 265-3211, schedule online, or send an appointment request. Texas Orthopaedic Associates, 7115 Greenville Avenue, Suite 310, Dallas, TX 75231. During football season, the Saturday morning injury clinic sees athletes from 8:00 AM. You can also read why patients choose Dr. Raynor as their Dallas shoulder instability surgeon.

Written and medically reviewed by M. Brett Raynor, M.D., board-certified orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon. Last reviewed 10/11/2026. General information for patients; it does not replace an examination.